The rivalry between Newcastle United F.C. and Everton F.C. has captured the attention of football fans for decades. These two English football clubs, each with its rich history and distinct identity, have met numerous times on the pitch, creating memorable moments for their supporters. The history of their matchups is a reflection of the changing dynamics of English football, from the rise of new managers to the evolution of the Premier League era.
In this article, we will take a deep dive into the Newcastle United vs Everton fixture, highlighting key moments, memorable games, and the impact both teams have had on English football. The timeline will cover notable matches, player performances, and events that have shaped the rivalry over the years. We will also answer common questions that people search on Google and YouTube to provide a complete view of the fixture’s history.
The Early Days: Formation and Initial Encounters (Late 19th Century – Early 20th Century)
Newcastle United F.C. and Everton F.C. first faced each other in the late 19th century. Both clubs were established in the late 1800s—Everton in 1878 and Newcastle United in 1892, following the merger of two clubs, Newcastle East End and Newcastle West End. During the early years, the matches between the two clubs were part of the footballing landscape in the First Division, which later became the Premier League.
Everton was initially the more successful of the two, with Newcastle United still in the process of establishing itself as a major force in English football. These early encounters were crucial in the development of both teams as they competed for dominance in English football. The matches were typically scrappy affairs, but they laid the foundation for what would become a fierce rivalry over the years.
Key Early Newcastle United F.C. and Everton Matches:
1899-1900: The first competitive encounter between the two clubs took place in the First Division, with Everton defeating Newcastle United 2-0.
1904-1905: A remarkable 3-1 win for Newcastle against Everton marked one of the early highlights of the fixture.
The Post-War Era: Rise of Newcastle and Everton (1940s – 1960s)
Following the interruption of World War II, both clubs began to grow in stature once again. The 1950s and 1960s were a period of transition, with both teams experiencing moments of success in domestic competitions.
Everton, in particular, enjoyed periods of success during this time, winning the First Division title in the 1962-63 season under manager Harry Catterick. Meanwhile, Newcastle United, despite a successful 1950s under manager Charlie Mitten, struggled at times in the subsequent decades. However, these matches between the two clubs continued to capture the public’s imagination due to the strength of both sides during the era.
Notable Games:
1951-1952: In a memorable 3-2 win for Newcastle, the Magpies demonstrated their attacking prowess, with notable performances from players like Len White.
1963-1964: Everton’s dominant 5-0 win over Newcastle was a statement of intent as they aimed for league glory.
The 1980s and 1990s: Competitive Balance and New Challenges (1980s – 1990s)
The 1980s and 1990s saw both Newcastle United and Everton battling for prominence in English football. This period was marked by major transitions for both clubs. For Everton, it was a golden age. Under manager Howard Kendall, the Toffees enjoyed great success, winning the First Division title in 1985 and 1987. They also triumphed in the FA Cup in 1995.
Newcastle United, on the other hand, faced a series of managerial changes and financial instability during this period. However, the 1990s marked the club’s revival, largely due to the appointment of Kevin Keegan as manager in 1992. Keegan’s free-flowing style of football led to a series of remarkable matches against clubs like Everton.
Key Matches from the 1980s and 1990s:
1983-1984: Everton defeated Newcastle 2-0 in a match that showcased the Toffees’ dominance in the mid-1980s.
1993-1994: A thrilling encounter that ended 3-3, with both teams demonstrating attacking flair. This match was part of the campaign where Newcastle began to challenge for the top spots under Keegan.
The rivalry during the 1990s was particularly interesting because, while Everton was highly competitive, Newcastle had a resurgence under Keegan, making every encounter between the two sides eagerly anticipated.
The Premier League Era (1992 – Present)
With the formation of the Premier League in 1992, the stakes of every match increased significantly. This era saw both clubs striving for top-flight success, with Newcastle United having a particularly strong early Premier League presence.
In the 1995-1996 season, Newcastle United finished as runners-up in the Premier League under Kevin Keegan, famously losing out to Manchester United after a dramatic late-season collapse. Meanwhile, Everton had its own struggles in the league, finishing in mid-table and undergoing several managerial changes.
The 2000s and 2010s have seen several key moments in the rivalry. Everton consistently finished mid-table, while Newcastle United enjoyed several seasons in Europe, particularly in the early 2000s under Sir Bobby Robson.
Notable Fixtures in the Premier League:
1999-2000: A late goal from Tomasz Radzinski sealed a dramatic 3-2 win for Everton over Newcastle.
2004-2005: In one of the most notable Premier League encounters between the two, Everton defeated Newcastle 4-1, with Wayne Rooney scoring a stunning goal that is still remembered by many.
2014-2015: In a heated encounter, Everton triumphed 3-0 at Goodison Park, with Romelu Lukaku putting in a dominant performance.
The Rivalry in Recent Years (2010s – 2024)
As the 2010s rolled on, both Newcastle United and Everton faced challenges on and off the pitch. Everton, under Roberto Martínez, qualified for the UEFA Europa League in 2014, but they were often inconsistent in the league.
Newcastle United, however, endured a roller-coaster period under various managers, including the controversial reign of Mike Ashley as owner. The team faced relegation battles in both 2015 and 2016 but managed to avoid the drop, particularly under Rafa Benítez in 2016-2017.
The 2020-2021 season marked a turning point for both clubs. Newcastle United was taken over by a consortium led by the Saudi Public Investment Fund (PIF), offering a potential new dawn for the club. On the other hand, Everton continued to be a mid-table team under manager Carlo Ancelotti, although their hopes of breaking into the top six were dashed.
Recent Encounters:
2021-2022: Newcastle United earned a memorable 3-1 victory over Everton at Goodison Park. The Magpies, buoyed by their new ownership, turned the game in their favor after going behind.
2023-2024: The most recent meetings have been close-fought affairs, with both clubs having various managerial changes. Everton, under Sean Dyche, and Newcastle, under Eddie Howe, have both shown improvements, and their encounters have been intense and closely watched by fans.
Key Players Who Defined the Rivalry
Over the years, several players have made lasting impressions in this rivalry, shaping the outcome of crucial matches.
Alan Shearer (Newcastle United): As the club’s all-time top scorer, Shearer has been a key figure in numerous clashes with Everton. His leadership and ability to find the back of the net made him a constant threat.
Wayne Rooney (Everton): Born in nearby Croxteth, Rooney made his name at Everton before becoming a superstar at Manchester United. His performances in matches against Newcastle were always filled with passion and skill.
Leighton Baines (Everton): The left-back was instrumental in Everton’s success in the 2010s, and his consistency on the field, particularly against Newcastle, was critical to the team’s defense.
Jonjo Shelvey (Newcastle United): Known for his passing and vision, Shelvey played a crucial role in several encounters with Everton, particularly in setting up goals.
FAQs
What is the Newcastle United vs Everton rivalry all about?
The rivalry between Newcastle United and Everton is built on both teams’ longstanding histories in English football. Although not as fierce as other Premier League rivalries, the matches between the two sides are often competitive, with both clubs vying for similar positions in the league.
Who has won more matches between Newcastle and Everton?
Historically, Everton holds the edge in terms of total victories. However, Newcastle United has had its fair share of wins, especially in recent years since their resurgence after the club’s takeover.
What has been the most memorable Newcastle United vs Everton match?
The 1995 FA Cup quarter-final match, in which Everton triumph
In Summary
The Newcastle United F.C. and Everton timeline is a rich and exciting chapter in English football, filled with memorable matches, key players, and dramatic moments. From the early days of their formation to the present day, the encounters between these two clubs have been integral to the Premier League’s history.
As both clubs continue to evolve, their matchups will remain significant for football fans, offering intense competition, tactical battles, and stories that will be passed down for generations. The future of this rivalry promises more exciting matches, with both clubs having ambitions to return to the top echelons of English football.
To read more, Click here
